Clove cigarettes, commonly referred to as kreteks (from the Indonesian onomatopoeic word for the crackling sound they make when burning), represent a distinctive category of tobacco products with a rich cultural history. These unique cigarettes combine processed tobacco with ground clove flower buds and various flavoring agents, creating a smoking experience markedly different from conventional cigarettes.
Composition and Manufacturing Process
Authentic kreteks follow a precise formulation that typically includes:
| Component | Percentage | Function |
|---|---|---|
| Tobacco | 60-80% | Primary nicotine source |
| Ground Clove Buds | 20-40% | Provides distinctive flavor and aroma |
| Nicotine | Varies | Often higher than regular cigarettes |
| Essential Oils | Small amounts | Additional flavoring (clove oil, nutmeg, etc.) |
The manufacturing process involves grinding dried clove buds into a fine powder, then blending them with selected tobacco varieties. This mixture is rolled into cigarette paper, often with a distinctive perforated filter that allows for the characteristic crackling sound as the cloves burn.
Historical Origins and Cultural Significance
Kreteks originated in Java, Indonesia during the 1880s when a young entrepreneur named Haji Jamahri began adding crushed cloves to tobacco to help alleviate respiratory discomfort. The practice quickly spread throughout the Indonesian archipelago, becoming deeply embedded in local culture.
By the early 20th century, kreteks had evolved from a folk remedy to a mainstream product. The Indonesian government eventually recognized their economic importance, with clove cigarette production becoming a major industry that supported millions of farmers and factory workers. Today, despite international restrictions, kreteks remain an important cultural symbol in Indonesia where they account for approximately 85% of the domestic cigarette market.
Distinguishing Features from Regular Cigarettes
Several characteristics differentiate clove cigarettes from traditional tobacco cigarettes:
- Flavor profile - The prominent clove flavor masks the harshness of tobacco, creating a misconception about reduced harm
- Burning characteristics - Produce a distinctive crackling sound due to the essential oils in cloves
- Smoke composition - Contain eugenol (from cloves) which numbs the throat, potentially enabling deeper inhalation
- Visual appearance - Often have darker tobacco mixture and distinctive packaging
- Smoking experience - Generally produce thicker, more aromatic smoke
Health Implications and Research Findings
Despite widespread belief that clove cigarettes are safer than regular cigarettes, extensive research tells a different story. Studies conducted by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and other health organizations have revealed that:
- Kreteks contain equal or higher levels of nicotine, tar, and carbon monoxide compared to conventional cigarettes
- The eugenol in cloves may cause temporary numbing of the throat, potentially leading to deeper inhalation and increased exposure to toxins
- They produce higher levels of certain carcinogens due to the combustion of clove compounds
- Smokers of clove cigarettes experience similar health risks including lung cancer, heart disease, and respiratory conditions
A comprehensive 2019 review published in the journal Tobacco Control concluded that "there is no evidence to suggest that kreteks are less harmful than regular cigarettes, and substantial evidence indicates they may pose additional health risks due to the chemical compounds released when cloves are burned."
Legal Status Around the World
The legal status of clove cigarettes varies significantly across different countries:
- United States - Banned since 2009 under the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, which prohibited cigarettes with characterizing flavors (excluding menthol)
- Indonesia - Legal and widely available, with significant cultural acceptance
- European Union - Subject to standard tobacco regulations, though some countries have additional restrictions
- Australia - Legal but subject to standard tobacco taxation and packaging requirements
- Canada - Legal but must comply with standard tobacco regulations
The U.S. ban specifically targeted flavored cigarettes, with clove cigarettes being one of the primary products affected. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) determined that flavored cigarettes, including kreteks, appeal to youth smokers and contribute to increased tobacco use among minors.
Common Misconceptions About Clove Cigarettes
Several persistent myths surround clove cigarettes that deserve clarification:
- "They're herbal and therefore safer" - Despite containing cloves, kreteks remain tobacco products with similar or greater health risks
- "They contain less nicotine" - Studies show nicotine content is comparable or higher than regular cigarettes
- "They're a good quitting aid" - No evidence supports kreteks as effective smoking cessation tools
- "They're only popular in Indonesia" - While originating there, they gained international popularity before regulatory restrictions
Current Market and Cultural Status
Despite regulatory challenges in many Western countries, kreteks maintain strong cultural significance in Indonesia where they're considered part of the national heritage. The industry supports approximately 2.5 million jobs across the clove cultivation and cigarette manufacturing sectors.
Internationally, some specialty tobacco shops continue to offer clove-flavored alternatives that comply with local regulations, though these typically contain minimal clove content to avoid classification as kreteks. The global market for traditional kreteks remains concentrated in Southeast Asia, with Indonesia accounting for over 90% of production and consumption.
Conclusion
Clove cigarettes, or kreteks, represent a unique tobacco product with deep cultural roots in Indonesia. While their distinctive flavor and aroma have attracted smokers worldwide, they carry health risks comparable to or exceeding those of regular cigarettes. Understanding what clove cigarettes are made of and their potential health implications is crucial for making informed decisions about tobacco use. Despite their aromatic qualities, they remain tobacco products with significant health consequences, and no cigarette, including those containing cloves, should be considered safe.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are clove cigarettes banned in the United States?
Yes, traditional clove cigarettes (kreteks) have been banned in the United States since 2009 under the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, which prohibited cigarettes with characterizing flavors other than menthol. This ban specifically targeted products where the flavor of cloves was the predominant taste characteristic.
Do clove cigarettes contain less nicotine than regular cigarettes?
No, research shows that clove cigarettes typically contain equal or higher levels of nicotine compared to regular cigarettes. The eugenol in cloves may create a numbing effect that allows for deeper inhalation, potentially increasing nicotine absorption and creating a false impression of reduced strength.
Are clove cigarettes safer than regular cigarettes?
No, numerous studies have shown that clove cigarettes are not safer than regular cigarettes. They contain similar or higher levels of harmful chemicals including tar, carbon monoxide, and nicotine. The burning of cloves produces additional compounds that may pose unique health risks, and the numbing effect of eugenol may lead to deeper inhalation and increased toxin exposure.
Where did clove cigarettes originate?
Clove cigarettes, known as kreteks, originated in Java, Indonesia during the 1880s. A young entrepreneur named Haji Jamahri is credited with creating the first kreteks by adding crushed cloves to tobacco to help alleviate respiratory discomfort. The practice spread throughout Indonesia and eventually gained international popularity before regulatory restrictions in many Western countries.
What makes clove cigarettes different from regular cigarettes?
Clove cigarettes differ from regular cigarettes primarily in their composition (60-80% tobacco and 20-40% ground cloves), distinctive flavor profile, and characteristic crackling sound when burned. They produce thicker, more aromatic smoke and contain eugenol from cloves, which can numb the throat and potentially enable deeper inhalation. Despite these differences, they contain similar or higher levels of harmful chemicals compared to regular cigarettes.
浙公网安备
33010002000092号
浙B2-20120091-4