The Ultimate Chicken Pot Pie: A Pennsylvania Dutch Recipe That’ll Make Your Kitchen Smell Like Grandma’s

Table of Contents

• Introduction
• A Taste of Tradition: The Origins of Chicken Pot Pie in Pennsylvania Dutch Culture
• Step-by-Step Guide to Making Authentic PA Dutch Chicken Pot Pie
• Spice It Up! Herbs and Seasonings That Elevate This Comfort Classic
• Pro Tips for Perfecting Your Chicken Pot Pie Game
• Serving Suggestions & Why It’s the Ultimate Family Meal
• Frequently Asked Questions About Chicken Pot Pie (PA Dutch Style)
• Conclusion: More Than Just a Pie — It’s a Legacy on a Plate

Introduction

Welcome to your new favorite Sunday dinner. No, really — if you haven’t tried authentic Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie yet, you’re about to become obsessed. Forget everything you think you know about chicken pot pies. We’re not talking about those sad frozen discs from the grocery store freezer aisle that taste like guilt and convenience.

Photo by Unsplash

This is the real deal — warm, buttery crust cradling a savory, herby filling that smells like home before you even open the oven door. If you’ve ever visited Amish country or been lucky enough to have a Pennsylvania Dutch friend invite you over for dinner, you know exactly what we’re talking about.

A Taste of Tradition: The Origins of Chicken Pot Pie in Pennsylvania Dutch Culture

Let’s get one thing straight — “Pennsylvania Dutch” doesn’t mean they’re from the Netherlands. It actually comes from the German word “Deutsch,” referring to the German-speaking immigrants who settled in Pennsylvania in the 17th and 18th centuries.

Fact	Details
Origins	German immigrant communities in Pennsylvania
Main Ingredients	Chicken, vegetables, gravy, flaky crust
Cultural Significance	Served during holidays, gatherings, and special occasions

Now, here’s where it gets interesting — chicken pot pie as we know it today wasn’t always called that. Some historians say it was originally known as “chicken pie” or “Dutch pie.” And no, it’s not technically a pot pie in the modern sense either. In many traditional PA Dutch households, this dish is baked in a deep dish without the top crust — more like a casserole with pastry boundaries.

Photo by Unsplash

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Authentic PA Dutch Chicken Pot Pie

Alright, let’s talk turkey… or should I say, chicken? Here's how to make an authentic Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie right in your own kitchen:

1. Brown the Chicken: Start with bone-in chicken thighs or a whole cut-up chicken. Brown them first in butter until golden brown.
2. Make the Gravy: Using the same pan, create a roux with flour and butter. Slowly whisk in chicken broth and milk or cream for a rich sauce.
3. Add Vegetables: Stir in cooked potatoes, carrots, peas, and onions.
4. Season Generously: Add salt, pepper, thyme, and other spices (more on this below).
5. Pour Into Crust: Pour the mixture into a pre-baked pie shell or a deep-dish casserole lined with crust.
6. Bake Until Golden: Top with a second crust or lattice top and bake at 400°F (200°C) until golden brown.

Photo by Unsplash

Spice It Up! Herbs and Seasonings That Elevate This Comfort Classic

While some recipes stick to basic salt and pepper, true PA Dutch cooks know that a few key spices can turn good into great:

• Fresh Thyme: Adds a subtle earthiness that complements the chicken beautifully.
• Nutmeg: A pinch gives warmth and depth — yes, really!
• Dried Marjoram: Similar to oregano but sweeter and less aggressive.
• White Pepper: For a smoother heat than black pepper, often preferred in creamy sauces.
• Mace: A lesser-known spice that pairs perfectly with poultry dishes.

Photo by Unsplash

Pro Tips for Perfecting Your Chicken Pot Pie Game

Ready to take your chicken pot pie skills to the next level? Here are our top insider tips:

1. Use Bone-In Chicken: It adds richer flavor. Don’t skip the browning step!
2. Don’t Rush the Roux: Let it cook gently so it doesn’t taste floury.
3. Thicken Before Baking: The filling should be thick enough to hold its shape when cooled slightly.
4. Blind Bake the Bottom Crust: Prevents sogginess — especially important for deep-dish versions.
5. Cool Slightly Before Serving: Allows the pie to set properly.
6. Make Ahead Magic: Prep the filling the night before and assemble just before baking.

Photo by Unsplash

Serving Suggestions & Why It’s the Ultimate Family Meal

You’ll want to serve this bad boy with:

• A side of buttered egg noodles
• Crispy coleslaw for contrast
• Warm, crusty bread and butter

And don’t forget the classic beverage pairing: homemade root beer or fresh lemonade.

Why is it the ultimate family meal?

• Comfort food at its finest
• Feeds a crowd
• Perfect for leftovers the next day
• Brings people together around the table

Frequently Asked Questions About Chicken Pot Pie (PA Dutch Style)

Can I use pre-cooked chicken?

Yes, but you miss out on that beautiful browning flavor. If you do, make sure to brown the chicken separately before adding it back in.

What’s the difference between chicken pot pie and PA Dutch chicken pie?

Traditional PA Dutch versions often omit the top crust and focus more on the hearty, creamy filling rather than a stew-like consistency.

How long does it keep?

Stored in an airtight container, it lasts up to 4 days in the fridge and freezes well for up to 3 months.

Can I make it gluten-free?

Absolutely! Use a gluten-free crust and substitute cornstarch for flour in the gravy.

Conclusion: More Than Just a Pie — It’s a Legacy on a Plate

So there you have it — the full scoop on making an authentic Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie. Whether you're hosting a family reunion, celebrating a holiday, or just craving something deeply comforting, this recipe will bring warmth, laughter, and plenty of seconds to your table.

This isn’t just comfort food — it’s culinary history, wrapped in buttery pastry and seasoned with tradition. So go ahead, roll up your sleeves, grab that rolling pin, and start smelling like the kitchen of someone’s happiest memories.